Baseball Articles

My 2023 IBWAA Hall of Fame Ballot

Boy, this year’s Hall of Fame ballot was uninspiring. Here is my vote for the IBWAA honors (which admittedly do not mean much, but I still take the vote seriously). I already analyzed the ballot, so I won’t go into detail about every players’ for-or-against case.

As far as the first-timers, I actually voted for Francisco Rodriguez. The ex-Mets reliever will never get in, but his stats were very similar to Billy Wagner’s, and he gets my vote every year. So I thought it might be hypocritical not to vote for K-Rod.

And Wagner, obviously. He is slowly climbing the ranks towards eventual enshrinement.

And I voted for Gary Sheffield once again. As I always explain, I vote for suspected PED guys if they never tested positive or were suspended. That’s why Alex Rodriguez and Manny Ramirez did not get my votes.

And that’s it — just those three (all former Mets, actually!). I took another look at Todd Helton, but I felt his peak was a little too short and the last half of his career was just pedestrian. However, I will revisit him again next year.

And Carlos Beltran? The cheating scandal aside, I was never convinced he was a slam duck Hall of Famer, so he does not get my vote. I might revisit him in the future, or I might not.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Why ask?